Track people, not %. In a church of 80, aim for 25–35 people re-engaging mid-week. One family can swing your % by 6 points. Count names, not numbers.

Days 1–30: 25–40% is a strong start. Day 90: 40–65% is healthy. Below 20% at Day 60 means the message is dying Sunday afternoon.

Segment by campus or cohort. Network avg 40–60%. Flag any campus below 25% at Day 60 for a campus pastor conversation — not a platform fix.

0%Healthy zone: 40–65%65%+

If Learn stalls below 20% at Day 60

Pastor completes the Learn step publicly — film a 90-second "I did this week's step" and send it to the congregation Monday morning. Nothing drives adoption like pastoral modeling.

Biblical anchor

"Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path."

— Psalm 119:105 · The Word that lives between Sundays

Connect Engagement Rate

Is the message producing relational movement?

Relational bridge

What it counts

% who responded to the weekly Connect prompt — posting a reflection, submitting a personal story, or engaging with another member's response.

What it does NOT tell you

The quality of conversation — that discernment belongs to the pastor reading the testimony content itself. Data tells you who; pastoral reading tells you what.

Healthy ranges

Know every name. In a small church, 2–4 Connect responses per week is meaningful. Each one is a pastoral data point — process them personally, not statistically.

Typically runs 10–20% below Learn rate. Gap >25 points signals a relational barrier: prompts may be too abstract, or members don't yet feel safe sharing publicly.

Track Connect by small group cohort, not just campus-wide. A group with high Connect but low Learn is processing relationally without cognitive anchor — worth a conversation.

0%Target: Learn −15%50%+

If Connect is persistently low

Read one Connect response aloud from the pulpit — with permission. This single pastoral act creates more relational permission than any platform prompt ever can.

Paired with Metric 1 — watch the gap between Learn and Connect

Live It Out Commitment Rate

The James 1:22 metric — doers, not just hearers.

Most diagnostic

What it counts

% who formally committed to a specific action step — a concrete, contextual behavior tied to the Sunday message that can be done at home, work, or in the neighborhood.

What it does NOT tell you

Whether they actually completed the action. Commitment ≠ completion. Over time, testimony submissions (Metric 4) begin to close this interpretive gap.

Healthy ranges

5–12 committed actions per week in a 100-person church is excellent. Celebrate by name: "Maria committed to calling her estranged sister this week."

Months 1–2: 15–30% of Learn completers. Month 3: 40–55% of Learn completers. Overall at Day 90: 20–35% of all active participants.

Flag any campus with Live It Out below 15% at Day 60. This is a preaching specificity issue — are action steps concrete or generic? Review sermon application language.

0%Target by Day 90: 20–35%55%+

Closing the gap

Preach with application specificity. "Be kinder this week" is not a Live It Out action. "Call one person you've been avoiding a hard conversation with, before Thursday" is.

Biblical anchor

"Be doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving yourselves."

— James 1:22 · The biblical mandate this metric measures directly

Stage Progression Gap = difference between Metric 1 and Metric 3 — see Metric 10

Testimony Volume & Trend

The fruit metric — John 15:8 made visible.

Read, don't just count

What it counts

Written accounts of how a message, action step, or Connect conversation actually changed something in a member's real life — submitted voluntarily each week.

What it does NOT tell you

Everything. Not all transformation surfaces as testimony. But the trend — rising, plateaued, declining — over 90 days is highly informative about your discipleship culture.

Healthy ranges

1 per 15–20 active participants/week. In a church of 80, 4–6 testimonies/week = strong testimony culture. Watch the trend, not just the number.

1 per 15–20 active participants. Three consecutive months of weekly growth = discipleship culture deepening. Absolute number matters less than directional trend.

Aggregate testimonies across campuses into a network Story Library. With member permission, these become your most powerful denomination-level discipleship asset.

The most important action for this metric

Read them. Name them from the pulpit. Let testimonies become the raw material for the stories your church tells about itself. One public testimony creates permission for ten more.

Biblical anchor

"By this my Father is glorified, that you bear much fruit and so prove to be my disciples."

— John 15:8 · The metric heaven tracks

New Member Follow-Through Rate (3-Week)

Are you retaining the people you reach?

Retention signal

What it counts

% of newcomers who complete all 3 weeks of the New Member Journey: Week 1 (Welcome & Belong), Week 2 (Learn the Mission), Week 3 (Take Your First Step).

What it does NOT tell you

Whether the newcomer is fully committed. Week 3 completion is a leading indicator of long-term integration, not a guarantee. A warm pastoral handoff at Day 21 is essential.

Healthy ranges

Track every new member journey individually. In a small church, this is not a statistic — it is a pastoral relationship being built or broken. Every newcomer matters intensely.

Below 40% → check enrollment friction, text personalization, or human welcome gaps. Above 65% → strong integration culture. Multiply documents +42% vs. pre-platform baseline.

Compare 3-week rates across campuses. Below 40% at a campus = campus pastor conversation, not platform adjustment. The data identifies where; pastoral presence supplies why.

0%Target: 50–70%80%+

The Day 21 pastoral handoff

Auto-trigger a personal staff connection at Day 21. The Connect responses Multiply collected about this newcomer give you warm context — this is not a cold call. It is a warm handoff from digital journey to human relationship.

Mid-Week Return Rate

Is the message still alive in their lives on Wednesday?

Habit signal

What it counts

Members who return to the Multiply platform on any day other than Sunday — indicating the message is still alive in their lives days after the service.

What it does NOT tell you

What they returned to do. Read mid-week return alongside Learn and Live It Out to understand what members are doing when they come back.

Healthy ranges

A mid-week return from someone you know by name is a pastoral conversation opportunity. Don't just track it — respond to it. A text or check-in deepens the habit.

40–60% of active participants by Day 90. Above 65% = platform has become part of weekly spiritual practice. Below 25% at Day 60 = habit not forming — review notification timing.

Segment by campus. A campus with mid-week return below 30% at Day 90 may have a notification delivery issue or a cultural engagement barrier worth investigating.

0%Target by Day 90: 40–60%65%+

Why this metric is one of the most revealing

Research confirms 90–95% of spoken content is forgotten within 72 hours without reinforcement. Mid-week return means the message beat those odds. That is worth naming from the pulpit.

Gifts Surfaced & Ministry Hands Raised

Movement toward service is a signal of spiritual maturity.

Pipeline metric

What it counts

Members who identified a spiritual gift, completed a SHAPE/Ministry Fit assessment, or actively raised their hand for a ministry role — through a sermon call or Multiply's discovery process.

What it does NOT tell you

Whether those who raised their hand were actually deployed. This metric creates a pipeline, not a placement guarantee. Your volunteer management system determines what happens next.

Healthy ranges

Every raised hand is a conversation. In a small church, 2–4 gifts surfaced per month = strong discovery culture. Follow up personally within 7 days — not a form, a conversation.

5–10% of active congregation raising their hand in any given month. Over 6 months on Multiply the gifts-surfaced count should accelerate as the Learn/Connect/Live It Out rhythm builds self-reflection.

Set a 30-day deployment standard: every raised hand in the digest receives a personal connection within 30 days. Track the deployment follow-through rate as a secondary metric in your staff meeting.

The staff meeting action

Every Monday: pull the gifts-surfaced column. Ask: "Who raised their hand this week and hasn't been contacted?" Assign a staff member. This is your volunteer pipeline — it's hiding in your dashboard.

90-Day Momentum Trajectory

The signal, not the noise. The trend, not the week.

Board metric

What it counts

A rolling trend line across all seven preceding metrics over 90 days — surfacing whether the congregation as a whole is trending toward deeper engagement or away from it.

What it does NOT tell you

Why a particular trend is happening. The 90-day view surfaces what — your pastoral discernment, staff conversations, and prayerful attention to individual stories supply the why.

Why 90 days specifically

In a small church, 90 days of consistent engagement from 20–30 people is a genuine culture shift. Don't dismiss this because the numbers look small. Small churches that move, move deeply.

Habit formation research: sustainable behavioral change requires consistent practice for ~66 days. 90 days gives you 30 days of margin beyond the formation threshold. A positive trajectory = culture taking root.

90-day aggregate is your board presentation metric. Single-week spikes and dips are noise. Use the 90-day line for strategic decisions; use weekly data for pastoral decisions.

At Day 90 — what to do

This is the first moment you have a complete story to tell. Present to your board. Host a testimony Sunday. Begin mentoring another pastor through your first 90-day arc. The story is ready.

Prayer Request Follow-Up Rate

Are you responding to the access people are granting you?

Pastoral care

What it counts

Prayer requests submitted through Multiply — and the % of those requests that received a documented pastoral or community follow-up response within the week.

What it does NOT tell you

The spiritual outcome of the prayer — that belongs to God. But it tells you whether your pastoral infrastructure is responding to the access people are granting you.

The standard

100% follow-up within 72 hours is achievable and expected in a small church. A prayer request submitted and not acknowledged tells that person the church does not actually care.

100% follow-up within 72 hours is the pastoral standard. Below 70% = assign a dedicated prayer/care team member to monitor this metric weekly. Every unacknowledged request is a missed pastoral moment.

Assign prayer request monitoring by campus. Any request 7 days without follow-up is a missed pastoral opportunity the digest makes visible. Build a care team accountability dashboard around this metric.

The pastoral weight of this metric

Prayer requests are the highest-vulnerability action a congregant can take. Followed-up requests deepen belonging. Unanswered requests erode trust — silently, and often permanently.

Stage Progression Gap

Where are your people stuck between hearing and doing?

Most diagnostic

What it counts

The ratio between Learn completion and Live It Out commitment — the delta between understanding the Word and obeying it. Expressed as a % gap between Metric 1 and Metric 3.

What it does NOT tell you

Why people are stuck — that requires pastoral presence and attention to Connect stories. But it consistently tells you where to look. It is the most precise diagnostic in the entire digest.

Reading the gap

Wide gap (Learn: 60%, Live It Out: 15%): knowledge-to-action barrier — usually a preaching specificity issue. Narrow gap (Learn: 55%, Live It Out: 45%): highly activated congregation.

Wide gap = knowledge-action barrier. A congregation that understands but does not act is not failing — they are hearing. The pastor's job is to close the gap through specific application and public celebration of Live It Out stories.

Compare Stage Progression Gap across campuses. A campus with a consistently wider gap than others may have a preaching culture or community expectation that needs pastoral attention at the campus level.

Wide gap: concerningHealthy: <20pt gapNarrow: excellent

The pastoral significance

A wide Stage Progression Gap is not failure — it is intelligence. It tells you precisely where to preach, where to create accountability structures, and where to celebrate obedience publicly when it happens.

Biblical anchor

"Well done, good and faithful servant. You have been faithful over a little; I will set you over much."

— Matthew 25:21 · The gap closed is the moment the Master speaks

Calibration Period

Day 30 — Establishing Baseline

The first 30 days are not a test. They are a starting line. Your congregation is learning a new rhythm — not proving whether they are committed.

What to watch

What % of your congregation has discovered the platform?
Which metric is highest? (Usually Learn — lowest friction)
Which is lowest? (Usually Live It Out — requires most intentionality)
Is new member follow-through above 40%?
Any testimonies at all? Even 2–3 is a sign of life.

What to pray

Ask God to soften the soil. In the Parable of the Sower, Jesus identifies four soil conditions before any seed bears fruit. Thirty days is planting time, not harvest time. Pray for openness, curiosity, and the Spirit to make the weekly rhythm meaningful.

What NOT to do

Do not present these numbers to your board as evidence of success or failure
Do not make platform changes based on one week of data
Do not compare your numbers to another church
Your 30-day baseline is yours alone — it is the beginning of your story

Prayer for Day 30: "Lord, break the silence in us. You said Your Word does not return void — teach us to receive it through the week, not just on Sundays. Let this rhythm become a means of grace in our congregation."

Pattern Recognition

Day 60 — Pastoral Diagnosis

By Day 60, earliest adopters have begun building a real weekly rhythm. You can now distinguish casual engagement from genuine formation.

What to watch

Is Learn rate climbing week over week, or has it plateaued?
Is the Stage Progression Gap narrowing? (Even 5 points = meaningful)
Are mid-week returns increasing beyond Mondays?
Are testimonies becoming more personal and specific?
Are newer members completing their journeys at higher rates than your first cohort?

What to diagnose

Learn >40% but Live It Out <15%: knowledge-action gap — address from the pulpit with specific Live It Out calls
Connect <10%: relational barrier — model vulnerability in Sunday services
Mid-week return <25%: habit not forming — examine notification timing and platform access

What to pray

Ask for perseverance — yours and your congregation's. Pray specifically over the names behind the numbers. If you have 18 testimonies, you have 18 people to pray for by name. Ask God to sustain those who have started, and draw in those who have not yet engaged.

First Full Story

Day 90 — The Story Is Ready

Day 90 is the first moment you have a complete discipleship narrative to tell. This is the moment for your first full board presentation on movement metrics.

Metric	Healthy at Day 90	Needs attention
Learn Completion	40–65% of active participants	Below 20%
Live It Out	20–40% of active participants	Below 10%
Testimony Volume	5–10+/week for 200-attendance church	Zero after 8 weeks
New Member Follow-Through	50–70% completing all 3 weeks	Below 30%
Mid-Week Return	40–55% of active participants	Below 25%
Stage Progression Gap	Narrowing from initial baseline	Wider than Day 30

Day 90 board presentation script

"Ninety days ago, we knew how many people came on Sunday. Today, we know that 147 of our members re-engaged with last week's message during the week. We know that 23 people committed to a specific act of obedience before last Friday. We know that 14 submitted written testimonies. And our new members are staying at 62% through Week 3 — compared to roughly 20% before. That is a different story than attendance."

Prayer for Day 90: Ask God to reveal what the data cannot. Ask for wisdom in shepherding those who are engaging but not yet acting. Ask for gratitude — because by Day 90, God has already moved in your congregation in ways the old scoreboard would never have surfaced.

Culture Shift

6 Months — What Kind of Church Are We Becoming?

The question shifts from "Is this working?" to "What kind of church are we becoming?" Six months is 26 weekly cycles — enough to observe whether the practice has become part of congregational identity.

Healthy 6-month signals

Members submitting testimonies voluntarily, without pulpit prompting
Gifts-surfaced backlog generated — volunteers ready for placement
Stage Progression Gap at or below 20 points
Newer members completing journeys at higher rates than months 1–2
Prayer follow-up rate approaching 90%+

Celebration milestone

Host a Testimony Sunday — 3–4 members share 2-minute stories drawn from 6 months of Multiply data. Don't celebrate the platform. Celebrate the people. What the congregation is witnessing is the Holy Spirit working through a community that chose to stay in the Word between Sundays.

What to pray

Intercede for those who are stuck — members with high Learn but no Live It Out across 6 months. These are the hearers James warned about: not rebellious, but passive. Ask God to stir in them a restlessness to move.

Leadership Emergence

9 Months — Multiplication Begins

By 9 months, the members Multiply has been forming are beginning to form others. This is where Multiply data intersects with leadership pipeline development.

What to look for

Who are the consistent testimony contributors? These members have developed a discipleship voice.
Whose gifts were surfaced in months 1–3 and have since been deployed?
Which small groups show higher Multiply engagement? Those leaders are culture carriers.
Is new member follow-through improving from months 1–3 to 7–9? If yes, your systems are learning.

The Ephesians 4:12 prayer

Pray that the saints are being equipped for the work of ministry, so that the body of Christ may be built up. By 9 months, your data will tell you whether equipping is happening. Pray by name for the specific leaders Multiply has helped you identify.

For denominational leaders

By 9 months, a pastor using Multiply has enough longitudinal data to contribute meaningfully to a network-level discipleship conversation. This is the moment for district superintendents to request 9-month digest summaries and begin building a network picture of movement across multiple churches.

The Long Story

12 Months+ — A Culture, Not a Program

After 12 months, Multiply data tells a story no single-year system can: the story of a congregation's culture shift from consumer Christianity to active discipleship.

Year-over-Year Comparison	What it reveals
Stage Progression Gap trend	Is the gap between hearing and doing narrowing year over year?
Testimony volume	Average testimonies/week in Year 1 vs. Year 2 — is the story culture growing?
New member integration	Is 3-week follow-through improving as your systems mature?
Ministry deployment velocity	Are identified gifts (Metric 7) being placed faster than in Year 1?
Mid-week engagement	Has the % of members with consistent mid-week engagement grown?

The Annual Harvest Report

Present a Harvest Report to your congregation each year combining: (1) old scoreboard data — attendance, giving, baptisms; (2) new scoreboard data — all 10 movement metrics from Multiply; (3) 4–5 featured testimonies that put a face on the numbers. This is the richer story your congregation has never heard before.

Video Overview

Replace VIMEO_ID_HERE
with your Vimeo video ID

⚠ Video Placeholder

Embed C — Movement Spectrum + Journey Maps

🔴 Dormant 🟠 Emerging 🟡 Growing 🟢 Moving 🌟 Multiplying

Interactive Diagnostic

Where is your church on the Movement Spectrum?

Answer 5 questions about your current Multiply data. Your result includes a condition diagnosis and a triage protocol tailored to where you are.

Question 1 of 5 — Learn Completion Rate

What percentage of your active congregation completes the weekly Learn step?

Below 15%

Very few people are engaging with the message after Sunday

15–35%

A growing segment is engaging, but most are not yet in the habit

35–55%

Real engagement — about a third or more re-engaging mid-week

55%+

Strong engagement — the message is clearly living beyond Sunday

Question 2 of 5 — Live It Out Commitment Rate

How many of your Learn completers go on to commit to a Live It Out action step?

Fewer than 10%

Very few are making the leap from hearing to doing

10–30%

Some are committing — the habit is beginning to form

30–50%

Solid commitment rate — genuine traction is building

50%+

Highly activated congregation — hearing is producing doing

Question 3 of 5 — Testimony Volume

How many testimonies does your congregation submit per week on average?

None or near-zero

The testimony culture hasn't formed yet

1–3 per week

Occasional testimonies — early signs of life

4–10 per week

A consistent testimony culture is building

10+ per week, growing

Testimony culture is deeply embedded — the fruit is visible

Question 4 of 5 — New Member Follow-Through

What percentage of new members complete all 3 weeks of the New Member Journey?

Below 30%

Most new members are slipping through the cracks

30–50%

Reasonable retention — room to grow the integration system

50–70%

Strong integration — the 3-week journey is working

70%+

Excellent — newcomers are becoming congregation members at a high rate

Question 5 of 5 — 90-Day Trajectory

Looking at the past 90 days, how would you describe your overall engagement trend?

Flat or declining across most metrics

Engagement has stalled or is moving in the wrong direction

Uneven — some metrics up, some flat

Progress is real but inconsistent across the congregation

Consistent upward trend across most metrics

The discipleship habit is forming across the congregation

Strong upward trend — gifts deployed, leaders emerging

The platform is producing multiplication, not just engagement

Triage Protocol — Do this first

What to pray

What NOT to do

Book a Discovery Call

All five conditions

🔴

Dormant

Learn <15%
No testimonies

🟠

Emerging

Learn 15–35%
Occasional testi.

🟡

Growing

Learn 35–55%
Weekly testi.

🟢

Moving

Learn 50–65%+
Multiple testi./wk

🌟

Multiplying

All metrics up
Leaders emerging

Choose your journey — I am a...

Community

Crowd

Congregation

Committed

Core

You are here

Journey Map 1

First-Time Visitor → Third-Time Guest

The critical 21-day window. Research shows fewer than 15% of first-time visitors return without intentional follow-up. This is where Multiply's 3-week New Member Journey does its most important work.

Day 1 — First Visit · Community → Crowd

The first encounter

Visitor encounters the church and makes an intellectual or emotional connection. Connection card submitted or QR code scanned → auto-enrolled in Multiply's 3-week New Member Journey. Monday after first visit: a personalized welcome arrives with Week 1 content.

Metric 5 watching: Did they open Week 1?

Days 2–7 — Week 1 · Crowd

"Here's who we are and why you matter here"

Learn: Who we are and why you matter here. Connect: "What brought you here? What are you hoping to find?" Live It Out: "Bring one person with you next Sunday." A first-time Connect response is often the most significant vulnerability action a newcomer takes.

Watch: Week 1 completion + first Connect response

Days 8–14 — Week 2 · Crowd → Congregation

"Here's our mission and how it connects to your story"

Learn: Our mission and how it connects to your story. Connect: "What would it look like for your life to be different a year from now?" Live It Out: "Text one person outside the church this week about something you're grateful for." Week 2 completion is the most predictive metric for long-term retention. Research shows 60% of people become part of a church after a third meaningful encounter — Week 2 completion sets up that encounter.

Most predictive: Week 2 completion rate

Days 15–21 — Week 3 · Congregation · Day 21 Handoff

"Here's your first step inside our community"

Live It Out: "Sign up for one thing this week — a group, a class, a serve opportunity." Week 3 completion + sign-up action = a visitor who has crossed from Crowd to Congregation. This is the transition Multiply's +42% follow-through rate documents. The automated journey triggers a personal pastoral or staff connection at Day 21. The Connect responses Multiply has collected equip that conversation — this is not a cold call. It is a warm handoff from a digital journey to a human relationship.

Milestone: Community → Congregation complete

Journey Map 2

Congregation Member → Committed Disciple

The most common arc on Multiply — the regular attender who is not yet deeply formed but who is open to growth. Months 1–6.

Stage	Primary Engagement	Stage Progression Gap	Pastor's Move
Months 1–2 Crowd → Congregation	Learn and occasional Connect	30–45 pts — Learn high, Live It Out low	Celebrate early Learn engagement publicly. Read one testimony aloud each week to create cultural permission.
Months 3–4 Early Committed	Learn + Connect converging; first consistent Live It Out	20–30 pts — narrowing	Introduce small group accountability around Live It Out steps. Invite high-engagers to mentor newer members.
Months 5–6 Committed	All three stages consistently; gifts-surfaced metric activating	15 pts or less — converging	Personal conversation about gifts deployment. Invite into a leadership formation cohort. Feature their testimony publicly.

What this journey looks like in the digest

A member who starts at 10% engagement in Week 1 and arrives at consistent 50–65% across all metrics by Week 24 has not just adopted a platform — they have built a discipleship habit. The 90-day trend line at months 5–6 for this member tells a story of formation that no Sunday attendance record could ever capture.

Journey Map 3

Committed → Core — The Multiplication Stage

The most spiritually significant transition — and the one most churches fail to design intentionally. Multiply's data creates the conditions for moving Committed members into Core. Months 6–12+.

Months 6–9 — Committed → Core Candidate

Signals that someone is ready

Consistent testimony submissions, gifts surfaced and deployed, high Connect engagement, emerging responsiveness to prayer requests. Pastor's move: Personal invitation into a Core formation conversation. Assign as a "Multiply champion" for their small group or ministry team.

Watch: Testimonies + gifts surfaced + prayer follow-up

Months 9–12 — Core

Discipleship reproducing

Their Live It Out actions now extend beyond personal practice — inviting or equipping others. Their testimony arc includes language of forming others, not just being formed. Pastor's move: Deploy as micro-course facilitators, testimony mentors, or co-leaders of a New Member cohort. A Core-level disciple who coaches one other member through the Committed journey has produced the New Testament's closest analog to discipleship multiplication.

Milestone: Disciple who makes disciples

The multiplication metric

Multiply does not measure this directly — but your pastoral knowledge of your digest, over time, makes it visible. A Core-level disciple coaching another member through the Committed journey is the New Testament vision of discipleship in action.

Journey Map 4

Inactive or Disengaged Member — Triage & Re-engagement

Not every journey is forward. Multiply's digest will eventually surface members who were engaged and then went quiet. This is not a platform problem — it is a pastoral relationship opportunity.

What the disengaged profile looks like in your digest

Learn rate: Was 50–60% in months 1–2, dropped to 10–15% by month 4

Testimonies: None in 6+ weeks

Gifts surfaced: None activated

Mid-week return: Near zero

Step 1 — Don't treat this as a platform problem

It is a pastoral relationship opportunity

Cross-reference with your CRM: Has this member's Sunday attendance also dropped? If yes, the disengagement is likely relational, not technical. The data has given you the intelligence — now bring the humanity.

Step 2 — Personal contact within 7 days

Not a reminder — a check-in

Not to scold, but to check in: "We noticed you've been quiet lately. We miss you. Is there anything we can pray about with you?" The Multiply digest made this contact informed and timely — rather than waiting until someone has been absent for months before anyone notices.

Step 3 — Re-enter at the right point

Reduce friction, not expectations

Don't re-onboard them as if they are a first-time visitor. They know the platform. Invite them back into the Connect step specifically — a single conversation prompt has lower friction than a full Learn cycle. Let the relationship re-enter before the metrics do.

Win: Any re-engagement within 30 days of contact

Video Overview

Replace VIMEO_ID_HERE
with your Vimeo video ID

⚠ Video Placeholder

Embed D — Telling the Story + Church Sizes + Language & Visuals

Part Five

Telling the Story

Scripts for every audience — ready to copy and use this week.

Data without story is just numbers. Story without data is just anecdote. The combination — a specific testimony embedded in a movement trend — is the most powerful discipleship communication tool available to a pastor.

Cadence

Weekly

30 seconds from the pulpit

Read one sentence from a testimony submitted that week. Anonymous, specific, real.

Monthly

2 minutes in a Sunday service

Report one trend in plain language. Name the number. Name the movement. Let the congregation see themselves.

Quarterly

5 minutes on a Sunday

Full movement report — combined old and new scoreboard, with 2–3 live testimony features.

Annual

The Harvest Report

A full year-in-review combining attendance, giving, and all 10 Multiply movement metrics into one congregational narrative.

Ready-to-use language

Introducing Multiply to your congregation

"We have always counted who came. Now we're starting to count what happened after. And what's happening after is what matters most."

Framing testimony data

"These aren't our numbers. These are your stories. They belong to you — and they're telling us something God is doing in this church that we could not see before."

Celebrating Live It Out commitments

"When 23 of us said yes to a Live It Out step this week, we were practicing the most important thing Jesus ever told us to do: not just hear — but do."

Reading a testimony aloud (weekly)

"Someone in this congregation wrote this week: [read testimony]. We don't know who wrote that. But God does. And so do they."

Monthly trend report

"This month, 34 of us submitted written testimonies of where God moved in our lives. That's up from 11 last month. The Word is taking root."

Elder boards have a legitimate stewardship responsibility for the numbers. The introduction of movement metrics should not replace that conversation — it should deepen it. Lead with one testimony before you show any data.

Opening a board meeting with movement data

"Before we look at the numbers, I want to read you something. One of our members wrote this to us this week. [Read testimony.] That is what the numbers are for. That is what we're trying to build."

The 90-day board presentation script

When the board asks — how to answer

Board Question	Movement Metric Response
"How are we tracking with new members?"	Our 3-week follow-through rate is 61%, up from an estimated 20% before Multiply. We're retaining newcomers at 3x the previous rate.
"Are our people growing spiritually?"	34 submitted testimonies this month — stories of specific life change. That's up 180% from month 1. Here is one I want you to hear.
"Is Sunday attendance translating to engagement?"	312 attended Sunday. 147 of them re-engaged with the message during the week. That mid-week return rate is 47% — and trending up.
"Are we getting an ROI on this platform?"	We have identified 14 new ministry hands raised this quarter — 14 volunteers who identified themselves before we had to recruit them.
"How do we know it's working?"	The Stage Progression Gap — the distance between people who understand the Word and people who obey it — has narrowed from 40 points to 18 points in 90 days.

The reframe principle

The old scoreboard isn't discarded — it's joined by evidence of what actually happened after Sunday. Frame movement metrics as an addition to the board's existing picture, not a replacement. The board that understands both scoreboards is the board best equipped to steward the church's mission.

Your staff meeting on Monday or Tuesday morning is the first operational venue where Multiply data becomes actionable. A well-structured reading of the weekly digest takes 10 minutes and produces pastoral direction for the entire week.

The Monday Staff Digest Reading — 10 minutes

2 minutes — Metric of the Week

Which single metric moved most this week?

Name it. Celebrate or diagnose it. Assign someone to follow up before Friday. One metric. One action. One owner. Don't try to address everything — address the one thing that most needs a response this week.

3 minutes — Testimony of the Week

Read one testimony aloud to the whole team

Ask two questions: "What does this tell us about where God is moving in our congregation?" and "Should this story be shared publicly, and when?" This is the most important 3 minutes of your staff week.

2 minutes — Triage Flag

Is any metric in a declining or Dormant range?

Name it without alarm. Assign the pastoral response for this week specifically. Who will reach out? By when? What will they say? The data has identified the person — the staff meeting assigns the shepherd.

3 minutes — Prayer

Pray specifically before you leave the room

Pray for the person behind the testimony. Pray for the members whose mid-week return rate has gone quiet. Pray for the new members in Week 2 of their journey. The digest gives you names. The prayer gives those names to God.

Opening the Monday digest meeting

"Every Monday morning, we get a report — not on Sunday's numbers, but on what happened after Sunday. It tells us where our people are moving. And where they need us to walk alongside them."

Conference and denominational leaders must shepherd pastors and churches, not individuals. The Multiply digest, scaled to a network context, becomes a tool for systemic discipleship accountability — the shift from counting function to measuring formation.

Opening a denominational conversation with movement data

"Our churches have always been able to report attendance and giving. What we have never been able to report — until now — is movement. Today I want to show you what movement looks like in our network."

The accountability shift

"For decades, denominational accountability has been driven primarily by attendance reports, pastoral assessments, and budget reviews. Multiply creates the possibility of a different kind of accountability — one rooted in formation rather than function. How is the world different because of the ministry of this church?"

Network best practices

Cohort Model

Quarterly pastor cohorts (8–12 churches)

Share digest highlights with one another. Creates peer learning rather than performance anxiety. The Moving church mentoring the Dormant church is more credible than any consultant.

Network Testimony Library

Aggregate testimonies across the network

With member permission, aggregate testimony submissions into a denomination-wide Story Library. These become the most powerful evangelism resource available to every church in your network.

Annual Movement Report

Replace the statistics report with a Movement Report

Include network-level Learn completion, testimony volume, new member retention, and gifts deployed — alongside traditional attendance and giving data.

Early-Adopter Mentoring

Moving churches mentor Dormant churches

Identify churches in the Moving or Multiplying condition. Assign them as peer mentors. Evidence that discipleship metrics are achievable — shown by a peer — is the most persuasive case for change.

Network metrics to track

Network Learn Rate: Below 30% = adoption challenge. Above 50% = discipleship culture spreading.

Testimony/100 participants: Compare across church sizes to surface strong testimony cultures for peer mentoring.

New Member Consistency: Which churches are consistently above 60% 3-week completion? Build peer coaching around them.

9-Month Digest Summaries: By 9 months, every pastor has enough longitudinal data for a meaningful network-level conversation.

🏡

Church Size — Under 150 Attendance

The Small Church Read

Karl Vaters' research confirms: metrics designed by megachurches do not work for small churches. Sample sizes make percentages statistically unreliable. Track people, not percentages. Every name matters. Every response is a pastoral data point.

Core Principle 1

Absolute numbers, not percentages. In a church of 80, don't track "35% Learn completion" — track "28 people re-engaged with the message this week." One family of 5 joining or leaving can swing percentages 6 points. Count people, not rates.

Core Principle 2

Know the name behind every metric. The pastor in a small church likely knows every person behind every submission. Read the digest the way the shepherd reads the flock — not "47%" but "Maria submitted a testimony about her marriage."

Core Principle 3

Testimony-first culture. Even 2–3 testimonies per week in a 100-person congregation = 2–3% story conversion — a rate that translates to enormous relational impact because everyone knows everyone. Read them all. Name them all.

Core Principle 4

New member journey weight. Every new member matters intensely. Track every single 3-week journey individually. It is not a statistic — it is a pastoral relationship being built or broken. Follow up personally, not programmatically.

Small church thresholds

Metric	Healthy (track as people)	Watch
Weekly Learn	25–35 people re-engaging mid-week	Below 15 people
Connect Engagement	2–5 responses/week — know each person	Zero 3 weeks in a row
Live It Out	5–12 commitments/week in a 100-person church	Below 3 consistently
Testimony Volume	4–6/week = strong testimony culture	Zero after 8 weeks
New Member Follow-Through	Track individually — every journey by name	Any journey abandoned in Week 1
Prayer Follow-Up	100% within 72 hours — always achievable at this size	Any request going 7+ days unanswered

⛪

Church Size — 150–500 Attendance

The Mid-Size Church Read

Mid-size churches face the most complex discipleship challenge: too large for the pastor to know everyone by name, too small to have large-church staff infrastructure. Multiply's digest becomes essential pastoral infrastructure at this size.

Core Principle 1

Segment by small group or ministry team. Track Multiply engagement by cohort — not just congregation-wide. Which small group has the highest Stage Progression rate? That group's leader is your discipleship culture carrier.

Core Principle 2

The 80/20 reality. Research suggests 20% of any congregation generates 80% of discipleship engagement. This is math, not failure. The pastoral goal is to grow that 20% to 30%, then 40%, over time. Track the trend, not the gap.

Core Principle 3

Staff alignment with the digest. Each ministry area — youth, worship, care — should have its own metric accountability within the overall digest. The executive pastor leads alignment conversations with data, not just intuition.

Core Principle 4

Percentage-based tracking is now valid. At this size, percentages are statistically meaningful. Use them for trends and board presentations. Still read individual testimonies — but % is the right unit for organizational decisions.

Mid-size thresholds

Metric	Healthy at Day 90	Emerging	Watch
Weekly Learn	40–65%	25–40%	Below 20%
Connect Engagement	Learn −10%	Learn −25%	Gap >25pts
Live It Out	20–35% of all	10–20%	Below 10%
Testimony Volume	1 per 15–20 active/wk	1 per 30–40	1 per 50+
New Member (3-wk)	50–70%	30–50%	Below 30%
Mid-Week Return	40–60%	25–40%	Below 25%
Stage Progression Gap	Below 20pts	20–35pts	Above 35pts

🏛️

Church Size — 500+ Attendance

The Large Church Read

Large churches face the inverse problem: the data is abundant and statistically valid, but the risk of managing metrics instead of people increases with size. Establish a discipline: no staff meeting reviews the digest without a testimony read aloud in full.

Core Principle 1

Aggregate for trends, disaggregate for pastoring. Use network-level data for strategic decisions. Disaggregate to site, campus, or small group for pastoral decisions. The larger the view, the more you need the story to anchor it.

Core Principle 2

Metrics-to-stories ratio. Establish a discipline: no staff meeting in which the digest is reviewed without at least one testimony read aloud in full. The larger the church, the easier it is to become fluent in percentages and mute to stories.

Core Principle 3

Gifts pipeline management. At large churches, the gifts-surfaced metric quickly generates more volunteers than the church can immediately deploy. Set a 30-day deployment standard: every raised hand receives a personal connection within 30 days.

Core Principle 4 — Multi-site

Movement equity across campuses. Compare Evidence of Movement across campuses. A campus with consistently lower Live It Out rates may indicate a different cultural dynamic. Compare to create curiosity and cross-campus learning — never to shame.

Large church thresholds

Metric	Network healthy	Campus flag	Action trigger
Weekly Learn	40–60% network avg	Any campus below 25%	Campus pastor conversation
Live It Out	25–40% of active	Any campus below 15%	Preaching specificity review
Testimony Volume	1 per 15–20 active/wk	1 per 50+ for 3+ weeks	Testimony culture intervention
Gifts → Deployed	30-day standard	Any hand uncontacted >30 days	Assign staff owner immediately
New Member (3-wk)	55–75%	Any campus below 40%	Enrollment friction audit
Prayer Follow-Up	90%+ within 72hrs	Any campus below 70%	Assign dedicated care team

Introducing the platform

"Every Sunday, we give you something to hear. Starting this week, we're also giving you something to do with it."

"This week's message has a second half. It lives on your phone from Monday to Saturday. It'll take you five minutes. It might change your week."

"We're not adding more content to your week. We're giving Sunday a longer life."

Describing the Evidence of Movement digest

"Every Monday morning, we get a report — not on Sunday's numbers, but on what happened after Sunday. It tells us where our people are moving."

"We kept one scoreboard. Now we keep two — and the second one tells the story the first one never could."

"Discipleship is your largest untracked investment. You know how many people showed up Sunday. You don't know what happened after."

Inviting testimony and engagement

"The best thing we could report to this church is not how many were here — it's what happened when you left."

"We are not anti-numbers. We're pro-counting what heaven celebrates. Views count reach. Movement metrics count formation."

"We count because we love each one — and the number 100 is never complete when one is missing."

Closing Word

The Shepherd Who Counts

A shepherd does not count his sheep to feel important. He counts because he loves each one — and because the number 100 is never complete when one is missing. The counting is an act of love expressed in arithmetic.

Multiply's Evidence of Movement digest is a tool for counting in love. It tells you how many showed up for the weekly Learn — because those 147 people matter, not because the percentage looks good in a board presentation. It surfaces a testimony from a member who called their estranged parent because a Live It Out action gave them the courage — because that story should be heard by the whole congregation, not buried in a database.

Count carefully. Shepherd faithfully. Celebrate often. And let the movement never stop.

Book a Discovery Call

Video Overview

Replace VIMEO_ID_HERE
with your Vimeo video ID

⚠ Video Placeholder

Copied to clipboard

The Movement EvidenceField Guide

The Movement Evidence
Field Guide